Leading housing lawyer and NRLA policy director David Smith says recent High Court ruling opens up possibility of evicting some tenants during crisis despite ‘ban’.
Some landlords might still be able to evict
troublesome tenants during the crisis using an injunction, despite the current
If they can show a very real need for urgently
removing an occupier, courts could grant an injunction, according to David
Smith, policy director at the National Residential Landlords Association.
However, this would only apply to a non-Housing
Act tenant in extreme cases – a residential tenant whose tenancy doesn’t fall
within the Housing Act 1988 – often tenancies to companies or very high value
He tells LandlordZONE: “A need would usually
be something around anti-social behaviour, such as an individual refusing to
self-isolate, so threatening the health of others in a shared occupancy house.”
While nobody has yet tried this in the
private rented sector, it’s likely that someone will, says Smith: “I have a
client at the moment who may do this.”
The Government gave tenants more protection by making
changes using the Coronavirus Act 2020, suspending all possession cases for
three months until 30th October with a practice direction. But this
specifically exempts any claim for an injunction, he explains.
“This has raised the question of whether a landlord can obtain an injunction which requires a person to vacate a piece of land or not to trespass on it, thereby getting round the limitations of the practice direction.”
Smith points to a High Court injunction last
week to remove a highly disruptive and abusive woman from a London hospital. He
says this is an indication that it can be done in rare cases where action is needed.
“A landlord with a residential tenant who did
not fall under the Housing Act 1988 could potentially obtain an injunction if
that tenancy had been ended because the tenant would have lost their rights and
would now be trespassing.
“Exactly the same position would apply for a licensor who had terminated a licence to occupy a room in their own house or a room in shared multi-occupancy accommodation – assuming it was a real licence of course and not a sham.”